Case Study: Turning HVAC Losses into a $41K Refund
Client Profile:
Industry: Commercial HVAC services
Revenue in Profitable Years: $450K–$600K
Tax Filings: Profitable first 2 years (2019–2020), net losses in Years 3–4 (2021–2022)
Background & Context
When our HVAC client engaged with us in mid-2023, they were navigating growing pains. Their expansion—new service contracts, equipment leases, and additional technicians—pushed operating costs beyond revenues in 2021 and 2022. Although they had paid corporate taxes of approximately $75,000 in 2019 and $68,000 in 2020, they reported combined non-capital losses of $120,000 over the next two years.
“We knew we had losses on paper, but didn’t realize we could turn them into a cash refund,”
– Client’s Internal Accountant.
Outcome & Metrics
Total Refund: $41,000
$36,000 from carrybacks at combined 26.5% average rate
$5,000 from provincial rate optimization
Processing Time: 8 weeks from submission to deposit
ROI for Client: Estimated 400% ROI on our fees and engagement cost
“The cash infusion transformed our Q3 operations, covering payroll gaps and funding a new service van,”
– Company’s Internal Accountant.
Ready to uncover hidden refunds in your filings?
Contact us today for a no-obligation assessment and see how much you could recover.
Our Role: Proprietary Three‑Phase Process
1. Historical Data Reconstruction
Extracted and validated P&L and balance sheet data from QBO and tax software.
Engaged in detailed interviews with the client’s accounting team to confirm timing of expenses and revenue recognition.
2. Loss-Carryback Strategy & Calculations
Mapped each year’s non-capital losses to the prior two profitable years.
Ran “what-if” scenarios to determine optimal split between federal and Ontario provincial rates, boosting refund by ~14% on provincial portion.
3. CRA Submission & Follow-Up
Prepared and filed Schedule 4 amendments on revised T2 returns for 2019 and 2020.
Drafted cover letters citing Income Tax Act sections for expedited CRA review.
Tracked processing timelines and liaised with CRA tax officers to resolve queries within 8 weeks.
Issue Identified
During our free assessment, we uncovered a key omission: despite clear carryback eligibility, the prior accountant:
Defaulted to Carrying Losses Forward:
Tax software settings were left on forward-only, so losses remained as future deductions.
Did Not File Schedule 4:
No loss-carryback requests were submitted to the CRA for any of the loss years.
Missed Federal vs. Provincial Rate Optimization:
Losses were not allocated between federal (9%) and Ontario provincial (11.5%) rates to maximize refund value.
Impact:
- Approximately $18,000 of potential refund left on the table for each loss year
- $36,000 cumulative unclaimed refund plus an additional $5,000 from optimizing provincial allocations
