Case Study: Rectifying $98K in Misclassified Shareholder Loans
Client Profile:
Industry: Technology services firm
Annual Revenue: $3M+
Ownership Structure: 2 shareholder-directors contributing capital
Background & Context
During our standard tax review, we examined shareholder transactions recorded in both the general ledger and tax filings. The owner had advanced funds into the corporation for equipment leasing and staffing payroll, totaling $98,000 over two fiscal years.
Outcome & Metrics
- Disputed Amount: $98,000 originally assessed as payroll income
- Resolution: All assessments reversed; no payroll taxes, interest, or penalties remain outstanding
- Timeframe: 12‑week audit process from initial reassessment notice to final determination
“Their proactive support was critical. Without it, we faced a six‑figure liability,”
– Company CEO.
Interested in safeguarding your shareholder transactions?
Get a free assessment today to ensure your capital contributions and loans are recorded correctly.
Our Role: Proprietary Three‑Phase Process
Audit Support & Documentation:
- Compiled detailed loan agreements and board resolutions to substantiate the shareholder loan nature.
- Assembled a transaction‑level audit trail matching bank deposits, GL entries, and corporate minutes.
CRA Negotiation & Clarification:
- Prepared a comprehensive submission to CRA auditors, clarifying the non‑employment nature of the funds.
- Coordinated conference calls with CRA tax officers to address follow‑up queries and present supporting evidence.
Amendments & Remediation:
- Filed corrected T4 slips and CRA remittance schedules to void the original payroll assessment.
- Adjusted corporate and individual tax returns to reflect proper treatment of shareholder loans.
Issue Identified
We discovered the previous accountant had:
Categorized shareholder loans as employment income:
$98,000 was issued on a T4 slip to the owner.
Failed to remit payroll taxes:
No CPP, EI, or income tax was withheld or submitted.
This misclassification prompted a CRA reassessment demand for unpaid payroll taxes, interest, and penalties.
